New York Knicks fans are divided over 'familiar' point guard's potential return to the team

Following an Eastern Conference Finals exit, the New York Knicks have worked hard to improve their roster.

The New York Knicks’ decision to fire Tom Thibodeau started a summer of massive changes for the team.

With Mike Brown taking over as the coach, the Knicks’ front office remains keen on adding more players. The organization recently signed Malcolm Brogdon to bolster its bench.

However, it seems like the Knicks aren’t done yet as they are reportedly working out a former point guard.

Photo by Emilee Chinn/Getty Images

New York Knicks fans are unsure about the team potentially signing Dennis Smith Jr.

Throughout the offseason, the Knicks have seemed keen on improving their guard depth behind superstar Jalen Brunson.

Following the signings of Jordan Clarkson and Brogdon, the Knicks are reportedly working out with Dennis Smith Jr., per insider Stefan Bondy.

The Knicks are bringing in a familiar point guard.

Dennis Smith Jr. is working out for the Knicks this week, league sources told the Post.

The former lottery pick hopes for an NBA return after playing last season at Real Madrid.

— Stefan Bondy (@SbondyNBA) September 14, 2025

View Tweet

Upon learning of the news, Knicks Nation was divided about Smith Jr. potentially returning to the roster.

“DSJ has become a really good defender, but his 3pt shot ain’t there,” one fan wrote. While another added: “I am all for it.”

“DSJ’s issues in the NBA have always been court vision & a consistent jumper,” a third fan stated.

“He actually was very underrated his last few years in the league,” a fourth fan reminded.

“It’ll be a non-guaranteed training camp invite,” another fan pointed out.

“Another epic failure of a season for the Knicks incoming,” a furious fan predicted.

Aside from fans being divided about Smith Jr.’s skills, the Knicks currently cannot even sign him to a permanent deal, as they already have a full roster.

Dennis Smith Jr.’s first stint with the New York Knicks

With Brian Windhorst labeling next season as a generational opportunity for the Knicks, each member of the roster will be key to making that dream a reality.

But does Smith Jr. even fit into this new timeline for the Knicks? After all, he was already out of the league as a 26-year-old.

Even putting that aside, Smith Jr.’s first stint with the Knicks lasted for three years, during which he played in just 58 games. He averaged 8.7 points, 2.4 rebounds, and 3.7 assists per game during that tenure.

Certainly not ideal numbers for a former lottery pick. Can DSJ prove his doubters wrong? It would be a huge gamble for the Knicks.

Source link