There is a cruel irony at the heart of Tottenham Hotspur’s season: even their victories come wrapped in defeat. Wednesday night at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium was the perfect encapsulation of a campaign that has gone spectacularly wrong almost from the first whistle.
Spurs were excellent. They beat Atletico Madrid 3-2 in a second leg that, on another night, might have sparked genuine belief in the miraculous. Xavi Simons was electric, Randal Kolo Muani sharp, and the crowd — 49,568 of them, generating one of the stadium’s better atmospheres of a difficult season — roared their approval. None of it mattered. The 5-2 hammering in Madrid three weeks ago had already written the story’s ending, and Atletico advance to face Barcelona while Spurs are left to contemplate a far more pressing concern: staying in the Premier League.
That is now the only thing that matters at N17.
The Champions League, so coveted after last season’s Europa League triumph, has ultimately proven a sideshow to a survival fight that few could have predicted when the campaign began. Thomas Frank is gone. Igor Tudor, the interim fix, has had a rocky ride — four defeats from his opening four matches hardly inspires confidence — but the last two performances have shown something different. Something more like a team.
Tudor himself was characteristically unsentimental at full time, striding down the tunnel without ceremony before offering measured words in his post-match assessment. “The sensations are mixed,” he admitted. Mixed is probably generous. He knows, as everyone does, that this is not his job to keep permanently. But he also knows he has done something in recent days that his predecessor couldn’t — he has made Spurs competitive again.
The numbers from the Premier League are still alarming. Twelve games without a win, stretching back to a victory at Crystal Palace on the final day of December. Six draws, six defeats. A slide that has dragged them into a relegation scrap alongside clubs with considerably more modest ambitions.
Sunday now becomes everything. Nottingham Forest arrive at the Tottenham Hotspur Stadium sitting just one point behind Spurs, level with third-bottom West Ham. A home defeat would be catastrophic in both practical and psychological terms. A win, by contrast, could shift the momentum of an entire campaign.
There were moments on Wednesday that offered genuine grounds for optimism. When Julian Alvarez restored Atletico’s three-goal aggregate lead two minutes into the second half, a lesser side — or this Spurs side of two weeks ago — might have crumbled. Instead, Simons responded almost immediately with a composed finish, and when David Hancko headed home a 75th-minute equaliser, hope briefly flickered. A Simons penalty in the dying seconds sealed the night’s result, if not the tie’s outcome.
It wasn’t enough. It rarely is this season. But for supporters who have spent months watching a team devoid of belief or structure, there was at least something recognisable — effort, organisation, and the occasional flash of genuine quality.
Tudor was careful to keep expectations grounded. “The last two games we have improved,” he acknowledged. “Sunday is important, but it will not decide anything yet. It will be decided over the last three games.”
He is right, technically. But football is as much about momentum as mathematics, and right now, Spurs have something they lacked for most of this wretched winter. Whether it is enough to keep them in the top flight remains the defining question of their season.
