Sunday, October 5, 2025
Submit Press Release
Got Action
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • NCAA
    • NCAA Football
    • NCAA Basketball
    • NCAA Baseball
    • NCAA Sport
  • Baseball
  • NFL
  • NBA
  • NHL
  • MLB
  • Formula 1
  • MMA
  • Boxing
  • Tennis
  • Golf
  • Sports Picks
  • Home
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • NCAA
    • NCAA Football
    • NCAA Basketball
    • NCAA Baseball
    • NCAA Sport
  • Baseball
  • NFL
  • NBA
  • NHL
  • MLB
  • Formula 1
  • MMA
  • Boxing
  • Tennis
  • Golf
  • Sports Picks
Got Action
No Result
View All Result

Knicks’ firing of Tom Thibodeau raises a question: What do we want from NBA coaches?

June 6, 2025
in NBA
0 0
0
Home NBA
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter


The New York City Democratic mayoral candidates have entered the Tom Thibodeau discourse.

During Wednesday’s debate, each candidate had to pick a side on the thumbs up/thumbs down binary about the New York Knicks’ decision to fire Thibodeau following their Eastern Conference finals defeat to the Indiana Pacers. Seven candidates did not agree with the Knicks’ move, while Michael Blake had the backs of James Dolan and Leon Rose.

“Our goal is to win the finals, not to get to the conference finals,” Blake said.

they asked the nyc mayoral candidates what they thought about the thibs firing

greatest city in the world

pic.twitter.com/SPxzyZiyzQ

— claire de lune (@ClaireMPLS) June 5, 2025

Regardless, the majority opinion on the stage seems to be the majority opinion in the greater sports world — or at least the initial majority opinion. Thibodeau just got the Knicks to the precipice of the NBA Finals and they were one of the last four teams standing for the first time in 25 years. These were not the lovey-dovey “Nova Knicks” of a year ago, thanks, in part, to the franchise-altering Karl-Anthony Towns trade that went down as training camp started. But the Knicks navigated it more successfully than not: 51 wins, the Eastern Conference’s third seed, two playoff series wins, including one over the defending champions (a series they had control of before Jayson Tatum’s injury) and a coin-flip conference final that might have gone the other way had the Knicks not blown Game 1 in historic fashion.

GO DEEPER

The Knicks’ season comes to an end, and Game 1 will haunt them for a while

On merit, Thibodeau should still be there. And what are sports if not an area of society in which we look for merit to win out in the end? There are enough aspects of life that aren’t determined by the concept of what’s deserved; sports are supposed to run counter to that. It is a deeply held value of many sports fans.

“When I first saw it,” Pacers coach Rick Carlisle said about Thibodeau’s firing on Wednesday, “I thought it was one of those fake AI things.”

Except, merit can have different meanings. We’ve heard that sports are a results-oriented business long enough that we usually believe it, but results are at once more complicated and simpler than ever before. Evidence for the latter: Blake’s comment — or, RINGZ culture, as some derisively put it. If winning a title is all that matters, and you believe you are a title contender, then the NBA becomes a zero-sum game in which only one team can be happy. If a team doesn’t win when it thinks it should, there is a hunt for reasoning. And if Thibodeau did not bring together a divided locker room, as was reported in The Athletic, did not maximize the skills of his team, as was evidenced by the team’s offensive struggles throughout the playoffs, and failed to extend his rotation until it was too late, why should he be back?

Another value sports fans hold dear: the importance of organizational alignment, from ownership to management to the coaching staff to players (and beyond). If management doesn’t believe in the coaches, or the players don’t believe in management, everything disintegrates. Right?

Well, if you believe that is a prerequisite for winning a title, let me point you to a little-known documentary called “The Last Dance.” Also, let’s go back to the surprise firings (in timing, if not in eventuality) of Denver Nuggets coach Michael Malone and general manager Calvin Booth from the last week of the regular season.

More so than in the Knicks situation, there was a clear conflict between those two values. Malone coached the Nuggets to their first championship just two seasons ago. To fire him so soon after a title (Nick Nurse, Frank Vogel and Mike Budenholzer have also lost their jobs shortly after winning championships in the last four years) seemed like an abandonment of merit.

Yet, there was an equal case to make that the Nuggets’ decision was overdue. Malone and Booth had been feuding long before their dismissals, causing fractures within the Nuggets. Despite Malone guiding the Nuggets to seasons of 57 and 50 wins (with David Adelman doing relief work in the latter year), ownership still held him accountable for not doing more to guarantee organizational harmony. At least in Malone’s case, he had company in the blame department.

The rub, of course, is that this had been a lingering issue, not a sudden one. Management and the coaching staff had disagreements leading up to the championship, but the Nuggets were able to overcome them. Everyone looks happy during a parade, but that doesn’t mean there aren’t simmering, perhaps unfixable, issues. (The issues worsened in the year following the title.)

Imagine if the Nuggets had fired Malone and/or Booth after last season, in which they lost Game 7 of the second round at home. Or if the Knicks had followed the lead of the Nuggets and Grizzlies by firing their long-time coach before the playoffs arrived. It’s not like they were a happy team as the season played out, nor were they significantly outperforming expectations. If you’re looking for a reason to change, you can always create one.

There is a straightforward reason for all these firings: competitive windows are closing faster than before. Player contracts are shorter, restraints on team-building in the new CBA are tighter and win-or-else angst is at an all-time high. There is less time to find the perfect recipe than there used to be. If you think you have a roster that can win, you better make sure you have the right leadership in place.

The question isn’t whether these firings are right or wrong, but why it feels like they can be both right and wrong simultaneously. It’s not that “deserve’s got nothing to do with it,” to borrow a phrase from”Unforgiven.” It’s that it has never been harder to determine what “deserve” means when it comes to leading an NBA team.

(Photo: Maddie Meyer / Getty Images)





Source link

Tags: CoachesfiringKnicksNBAQuestionraisesThibodeauTom
Previous Post

Moving On From a Slump

Next Post

Braves trivia: Your in-5 daily game, Friday edition

Related Posts

JJ Redick Says Bronny James Much More Comfortable And Confident Despite Shooting Struggles
NBA

JJ Redick Says Bronny James Much More Comfortable And Confident Despite Shooting Struggles

October 4, 2025
Bronny James cold in 1st Lakers preseason game; Redick praises
NBA

Bronny James cold in 1st Lakers preseason game; Redick praises

October 4, 2025
Lakers lose their pre-season opener to Suns with James, Doncic sitting out
NBA

Lakers lose their pre-season opener to Suns with James, Doncic sitting out

October 4, 2025
How report out of players-only meeting changed vibes of last season’s 76ers
NBA

How report out of players-only meeting changed vibes of last season’s 76ers

October 3, 2025
Abdou Toure Commits To Arkansas
NBA

Abdou Toure Commits To Arkansas

October 3, 2025
How will the Clippers 11-man rotation work? Analyzing assignments and expectations
NBA

How will the Clippers 11-man rotation work? Analyzing assignments and expectations

October 3, 2025
Next Post
Braves trivia: Your in-5 daily game, Friday edition

Braves trivia: Your in-5 daily game, Friday edition

Should the Cincinnati Reds be sellers? Buyers?

Should the Cincinnati Reds be sellers? Buyers?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Trending
  • Comments
  • Latest
Away Attendances at the Weekend – 8th September 2025

Away Attendances at the Weekend – 8th September 2025

September 8, 2025
How to Buy COTA Tickets – 2025 United States Grand Prix

How to Buy COTA Tickets – 2025 United States Grand Prix

March 12, 2025
Is Max Verstappen in the mix to win the 2025 Drivers’ title?

Is Max Verstappen in the mix to win the 2025 Drivers’ title?

September 25, 2025
Marte, Steer power Cincinnati Reds over Pittsburgh, 14-8

Marte, Steer power Cincinnati Reds over Pittsburgh, 14-8

August 10, 2025
Arthur Jones, who won a Super Bowl with the Ravens, dies at 39

Arthur Jones, who won a Super Bowl with the Ravens, dies at 39

October 4, 2025
Fans urge Miami Heat to sign former MVP after Tyler Herro surgery news, ‘he’d immediately be the best player’

Fans urge Miami Heat to sign former MVP after Tyler Herro surgery news, ‘he’d immediately be the best player’

September 19, 2025
Anthony Davis could return to Mavericks’ lineup during upcoming Eastern road trip: Report

Anthony Davis could return to Mavericks’ lineup during upcoming Eastern road trip: Report

233
Getting with the programme | Arseblog … an Arsenal blog

Getting with the programme | Arseblog … an Arsenal blog

3
The longest an NCAA bracket has ever stayed perfect

The longest an NCAA bracket has ever stayed perfect

1
Hanshin Tigers shut out Cubs, Dodgers for back-to-back wins

Hanshin Tigers shut out Cubs, Dodgers for back-to-back wins

1
Avious Griffin Highlights Boxing Insider Promotion’s Card By Stopping Jose Luis Sanchez In 9.

Avious Griffin Highlights Boxing Insider Promotion’s Card By Stopping Jose Luis Sanchez In 9.

1
Sabres starting goalie Luukkonen expected to miss season opener

Sabres starting goalie Luukkonen expected to miss season opener

0
Ryan Garcia Shows Blazing Speed After Hand Surgery

Ryan Garcia Shows Blazing Speed After Hand Surgery

October 5, 2025
Pittsburgh QB Mason Heintschel (4 TDs) shines in first start

Pittsburgh QB Mason Heintschel (4 TDs) shines in first start

October 4, 2025
UFC 320: Ankalaev vs. Pereira 2 Live Results and Analytics

UFC 320: Ankalaev vs. Pereira 2 Live Results and Analytics

October 4, 2025
Previewing The 2025-26 Free Agent Class: Catcher

Previewing The 2025-26 Free Agent Class: Catcher

October 4, 2025
Milwaukee Brewers OF Jackson Chourio exits Game 1 injured

Milwaukee Brewers OF Jackson Chourio exits Game 1 injured

October 4, 2025
What are the tactical options for the Singapore Grand Prix?

What are the tactical options for the Singapore Grand Prix?

October 4, 2025
Facebook Twitter Instagram LinkedIn TikTok Pinterest
Got Action

Stay updated with the latest sports news, highlights, and expert analysis at Got Action. From football to basketball, we cover all your favorite sports. Get your daily dose of action now!

CATEGORIES

  • Baseball
  • Basketball
  • Boxing
  • Football
  • Formula 1
  • Golf
  • MLB
  • MMA
  • NBA
  • NCAA Baseball
  • NCAA Basketball
  • NCAA Football
  • NCAA Sport
  • NFL
  • NHL
  • Tennis
  • Uncategorized

SITEMAP

  • About us
  • Advertise with us
  • Submit Press Release
  • Disclaimer
  • Privacy Policy
  • DMCA
  • Cookie Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact us

Copyright © 2025 Got Action.
Got Action is not responsible for the content of external sites.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Football
  • Basketball
  • NCAA
    • NCAA Football
    • NCAA Basketball
    • NCAA Baseball
    • NCAA Sport
  • Baseball
  • NFL
  • NBA
  • NHL
  • MLB
  • Formula 1
  • MMA
  • Boxing
  • Tennis
  • Golf
  • Sports Picks
Submit Press Release

Copyright © 2025 Got Action.
Got Action is not responsible for the content of external sites.