Top Heisman Trophy Contenders: Who Has the Best Odds This Season?

The Heisman Trophy is the most coveted individual award in college football. The race to claim it typically is filled with dramatic shifts, fueled by remarkable games, unexpected upsets, and rising stars who exceed expectations. 

This year’s Heisman race features a strong group of contenders who have already shown their potential to dominate. Their performances in key games, combined with their leadership on the field, will shape their journey toward the award. 

Let’s take a look at the top 5 most likely candidates to win this honor based on current odds.

Arch Manning (Texas) – +700

Arch Manning enters the season with the highest odds to win the Heisman, sitting at +700. The Texas quarterback has been the focus of national attention, and his skill set makes him a dangerous weapon for the Longhorns. Last season, he completed 68% of his passes, throwing for 939 yards and 13 total touchdowns in limited action. With more playing time this year, he has a chance to make a significant leap.

Texas boasts a strong supporting cast that can help Manning showcase his talent. His accuracy and decision-making allow him to operate efficiently within the offense. A deep receiving corps and a solid offensive line give him the tools to produce Heisman-worthy numbers.  

The Longhorns’ success will also be critical in boosting Manning’s chances. A winning season, especially with victories against top-ranked opponents, will strengthen his Heisman case. If he continues to develop and leads Texas to a College Football Playoff berth, he could cement his status as the frontrunner.

Garrett Nussmeier (LSU) – +850

Garrett Nussmeier has quickly gained recognition as a top Heisman candidate, with +850 odds reflecting his potential. LSU’s quarterback took command of the offense last season, throwing for 4,052 yards and 29 touchdowns. His ability to stretch the field with deep throws has made him a key playmaker for the Tigers.

Online sports betting trends influence Nussmeier’s odds, which shift as the season progresses. LSU’s offensive system gives him a platform to put up impressive numbers. He thrives in a fast-paced attack that prioritizes explosive plays.  

High-stakes matchups provide the perfect stage for Nussmeier to prove himself. Strong leadership in key games could push LSU toward a successful season and elevate his standing in the Heisman race.

Cade Klubnik (Clemson) – +1100

Cade Klubnik enters the season with +1100 odds, carrying the expectations of leading Clemson back to national prominence. The Tigers’ quarterback put together an impressive 2024 season, throwing for 3,639 yards while adding 463 rushing yards and 43 total touchdowns. His dual-threat ability makes him a unique weapon in college football.

Klubnik’s versatility allows Clemson to run a balanced attack. His ability to make plays through the air and on the ground keeps defenses off balance. The team’s offensive scheme puts him in position to succeed, and his leadership will be crucial in navigating a tough schedule. 

Clemson’s playoff hopes will play a major role in determining Klubnik’s Heisman trajectory. Shining in marquee games will strengthen Klubnik’s Heisman case. Leading Clemson to major victories would solidify his status as a top contender. Maintaining efficiency while producing highlight-reel moments will be key to his campaign.

Jeremiah Smith (Ohio State) – +1200

Jeremiah Smith is the only wide receiver among the top contenders, holding +1200 odds. He burst onto the national scene last season, playing a pivotal role in Ohio State’s championship run. As a 17-year-old freshman, he displayed elite route-running and playmaking ability, making him one of the most dangerous offensive weapons in college football.

Winning the Heisman as a wide receiver is a rare feat, but Smith has the talent to challenge history. His ability to take over games with explosive plays gives him a strong case. If he continues to put up big numbers and deliver game-changing moments, voters may be forced to consider him as a serious contender. His rising stock is reflected in FanDuel NCAAF Player Trends, which track his increasing impact on the Buckeyes’ offense.

Ohio State’s championship hopes will be key to Smith’s Heisman chances. If the Buckeyes remain in the title hunt and Smith continues to dominate, he could emerge as a serious contender. A standout season with record-breaking statistics would make his case undeniable.

Drew Allar (Penn State) – +1300

Drew Allar rounds out the top five with +1300 odds. Penn State’s quarterback has steadily developed into a reliable leader, guiding the Nittany Lions to a College Football Playoff semifinal appearance last season. His poise and strong arm make him a valuable asset in Penn State’s offensive system.

Allar’s ability to control the game and make smart decisions will be critical to his Heisman campaign. His accuracy and efficiency give Penn State a consistent passing attack, and his leadership has helped elevate the team. Continued improvement and smarter decision-making will strengthen Allar’s Heisman case. A more polished game would make him a stronger contender for the award.

Penn State’s title aspirations will play a key role in Allar’s Heisman case. Strong performances in critical games would boost his standing in the race. A dominant season could put him in serious contention for college football’s top individual honor.

One Season to Shape a Legacy

Winning the Heisman Trophy is a career-defining achievement. The players in this race have proven they belong among the best, but only one will etch their name into history. Over the next few months, standout performances and unforgettable moments will decide who rises above the rest. Stay tuned—the road to greatness is just beginning!