If Newcastle United needed another painful reminder of their reality at Anfield, this match delivered it with theatrical cruelty. There are bad days in football, there are collapses, and then there is whatever peculiar psychological vortex Newcastle fall into whenever they cross the white line at Liverpool’s historic home.
This was supposed to be the night the streak finally cracked. For 40 minutes, Newcastle were not just competitive; they were the better side. They ran Liverpool ragged, pressed with conviction, countered with purpose, and led with full merit through Anthony Gordon. And then—just as they have done so many times before—they unravelled. The self‑destruction was sudden, dramatic, and utterly predictable.
Newcastle’s tortured record here stretches back to 1994 – a truly staggering fact. Thirty‑plus years of failure have left scar tissue on the fixture, and once again—almost ritualistically—their hopes dissolved under the Anfield lights.
Hope, Interrupted Again
For much of the first half, Newcastle offered something enticing: control. Liverpool couldn’t get out. Eddie Howe’s game plan—a compact structure with aggressive pressure on Liverpool’s improvised back line—was working. Anthony Gordon’s goal looked like the ignition of a performance finally worthy of ending the curse.
But if Anfield is Liverpool’s cathedral, then Newcastle are the ideal visiting sermon illustration of human frailty. Just before half‑time, they folded in two blinks of an eye.
Mo Salah’s deflected shot fell awkwardly into the path of Ryan Gravenberch, who nudged it to Florian Wirtz. Three Newcastle defenders converged and somehow none of them intevened. Wirtz slipped the ball to Hugo Ekitike, who tapped it in. One moment of hesitation, one tangle of feet, and the score was level.
Howe’s reaction said everything. Normally a figure of examplery composure, he snapped into fury—arms flailing, expletives spilling toward Jason Tindall, gesturing at ghosts only he could see. It was the face of a manager who had watched this movie too many times.
Two Minutes of Madness That Changed Everything
At 1-1, with half-time seconds away, Newcastle needed calm. They needed to reach the dressing room. Instead, they invited chaos.
A routine corner for Newcastle fizzled out, and one long, hopeful punt from Milos Kerkez upfield found Ekitike near halfway. Sandro Tonali was tracking, Malick Thiaw had the pace and positioning to cover. There was no real threat.
And then Thiaw simply… stopped. Slowed to a jog. Dared Ekitike to run. And run he did, leaving Thiaw embarrassingly flat‑footed before curling a stunning outside‑of‑the‑boot finish past Nick Pope.
Embed from Getty Images
In that moment, it looked like Thiaw was trying to emulate a prime Virgil van Dijk, who often used what looked like a nonchalant approach in one-on-one situations, directing attackers where he wanted them to go, before snapping in to deal with the danger. Well, everyone at Newcastle will be hoping Thiaw has learned his lesson: he is not Virgil van Dijk as he is now, let alone back in the Liverpool captain’s prime.
In those unforgivable five seconds, Newcastle didn’t just lose their lead—they surrendered the entire emotional blueprint of the match. Howe stood on the touchline with the expression of a man who had just seen a victory turn into defeat, unable to do anything about it. Mouth open. Eyes hollow. Disbelief turning into the fatalistic acceptance that comes only at Anfield.
Seconds later, cameras caught him squatting on the turf, staring at the ground as if contemplating life choices. Anyone who has followed Newcastle’s three‑decade dance with this stadium knew the truth: the game was over.
The Inevitable Thumping
Newcastle supporters in the media joked before kickoff that a 4–1 defeat felt inevitable. It had become a kind of gallows humour, a coping mechanism for a fixture that has mutated into an annual trauma.
And so, of course, it finished 4–1.
Thiaw’s mistake in the build‑up to Liverpool’s third goal was as careless as his jog for the second. And then came the fourth: Nick Pope, usually trustworthy, dropped the simplest of crosses. Ibrahima Konaté swung a shin at the bouncing ball. It ricocheted off Dan Burn’s backside and rolled apologetically into the net.
If you scripted a slapstick goal to symbolise 32 years of misery, this would be it.
Liverpool did not simply beat Newcastle; they punished them. Picked at their confidence. Exposed their insecurities. Turned their early superiority into dust. It wasn’t a rivalry; it was a rerun of a long‑running tragicomedy.
A Manager Running Out of Answers
Eddie Howe is not a naïve man. He understands psychology, preparation, structure. But something about Anfield dissolves Newcastle’s resolve, turning experienced professionals into panicked amateurs. Howe has now had four years and multiple opportunities to break the spell, and yet he appears as baffled as his predecessors.
Embed from Getty Images;
Sixteen permanent managers have attempted the same task since 1994. Sixteen have failed. Twelve different Newcastle captains have tried to lift the curse. They all fell short. The one common thread has been not systems, not personnel, not tactics—but the mentality that seems to crumble in this stadium.
Howe’s Newcastle are not a brittle team by nature. They have outplayed top sides, ground out results, punched above their weight in Europe, and shown remarkable growth. But Anfield makes them regress, unravel, and implode.
Why This Defeat Hurts More Than the Others
Newcastle have been thrashed at Anfield before. Many times. But this one cuts deeper.
Because they played well. They dominated early. They had Liverpool bent into uncomfortable shapes. They led. They were the aggressors, not the survivors. This wasn’t a mismatch—it was a meltdown.
Newcastle had the rarest gift of all: belief. And they blew it.
The defending was soft. The transitions were sloppy. The decision‑making evaporated under pressure. The composure that had defined their opening 40 minutes was replaced by panic, lapse, and confusion. This wasn’t just losing—it was self‑sabotage.
It was a reminder that for all the progress Newcastle have made under Howe, they still possess an Achilles’ heel that surfaces under the brightest lights.
